Thinking out loud: Are electric vehicles as sustainable as we believe?

electric vehicles

The core of modern civilisation lies in our mobility. Mobility impacts many aspects of life and as our lives grow more individual, it helps us in reaching towards the indispensable.

The next generation will see a transformative shift towards electrification in automobiles, moving away from internal combustion engines (ICE) that will likely be phased out.

The global electric vehicle (EV) market was valued at US$162 billion in 2019 and is projected to be valued at US$1,212 billion by 2027. An increase in demand for fuel-efficient, high-performance, and low-emission vehicles along with stringent government rules and regulations toward vehicle emission will supplement the growth of the electric vehicle market.

EV batteries remain the main barrier in the conversion to electric vehicles. Once only seen fit to power small consumer electronic goods such as alarm clocks and laptops, batteries are now moving upstream to power larger appliances from e-bikes to vehicles. Driving the move towards electrification is the rapid development of lithium-ion batteries.

The International Energy Agency (IEA) in its 2020 Global EV Outlook highlighted that sales of EVs in 2019 grew by 2.1 million worldwide. This boosted total stock in the market to 7.2 million from 5.1 million in 2018.

Electric cars in 2019 registered a 40 per cent year-on-year increase, accounting for 2.6 per cent of global car sales – roughly one per cent of global car stock. The rise and adoption of EVs are a sharp contrast to 2010 where only about 17,000 electric cars were on the road.

As countries try to reduce their carbon emissions and footprint in line with The Paris Agreement, EVs and batteries will play a crucial role moving forward.

Also Read: “Singapore isn’t ready for mass adoption of EVs yet; hybrid may be better for the present”

An EV battery presently accounts for almost 30 per cent of the total cost of an electric vehicle. Thus lies the main pain point faced by battery manufacturers and automotive OEMs – the cost to manufacture these batteries.

Developments in battery technology and manufacturing capabilities have driven prices of lithium-ion batteries down from US$1,000 a kilowatt-hour in 2010 to an average of US$156 per kilowatt-hour as of the end of 2019.

Although prices of batteries have significantly decreased, it has yet to reach the price-parity ratio suitable for mass adoption.

With the future of electrification on the horizon, existing traditional automotive manufacturers are converting and diverting resources to develop EVs. Together with new and upcoming companies that are either developing EVs and/or other related EV components such as battery swaps and charging stations, this space is heating up.

While Chinese EVs are focused on the hybrid model of battery swaps and charging stations, Tesla and other manufacturers in the West are adopting the Tesla model of building charging stations with high-powered piles.

Chinese EV maker Nio pioneered battery swapping technology in 2014. It has surpassed two million battery swaps and has over 190 Power Swap Stations in 59 Chinese cities. Nio’s battery swapping station only requires three-minutes to swap a depleted battery with a fully charged battery.

In addition to the battery swapping stations, Nio provides charging stations similar to Tesla’s fast chargers dubbed “Power Chargers” – currently the world’s slimmest and takes half an hour to charge to 80 per cent from 20 per cent.

The biggest advantage of battery swapping is the reduction in costs and thus prices of cars.

Also Read: Grab, Hyundai launches their first electric vehicle service in Indonesia

That said, many battery experts argue that battery swaps only serve as a transitional solution for consumer vehicles at this point and may face scalability issues for large commercial vehicles.

Challenges remain in the production of lithium-ion batteries despite the drop in production costs as it is still in its infancy and many variables remain uncertain.

Production of lithium-ion batteries face environmental and structural issues and continue to fuel debate. Extraction of lithium results in energy and water wastage, with long term impact found in the surrounding soil and water quality.

On average, producing an EV contributes twice as much to its Global Warming Potential (GWP) and uses double the amount of energy compared to a standard combustion engine. The fabrication of an EV battery accounts for 70 per cent of the EV GWP and is likely to result in emissions of more than eight tonnes of carbon dioxide.

The world’s biggest EV battery maker Contemporary Amperex Technology Ltd (CATL) has invested in overseas plants in Germany and Indonesia. Growing appetite for batteries has led to higher demand for cobalt and other critical minerals important to battery manufacturing.

In a bid to fulfil the surge in demand and to reduce dependency on critical minerals, cobalt which was once seen as the heart of lithium-ion batteries is being steadily reduced in content.

This was in part due to the negative connotation attached to it. Cobalt comes predominantly from the Democratic Republic of Congo where workers exposed to terrible conditions mine and extract the mineral, earning it a nickname as “Blood Cobalt”.

Looking beyond the limitations of lithium-ion batteries, the commercial use of solid-state lithium-ion in EVs would mitigate a majority of the current issues faced and could fundamentally change the perception of EVs with the general public.

Also Read: ION Mobility secures US$3.3M to drive SEA’s 200M motorcycle users to use EVs, starting with Indonesia

A key concern with consumers is the range and distance at which the cars can travel. The Tesla Model S Long Range currently holds the longest range, going a maximum of 600km under ideal situations.

A recent study by Castrol noted that  469km is the minimum range an EV needs to cover to ensure the occupants does not succumb to range anxiety under daily operations.

The long-term future of EVs lies in the development of solid-state batteries. Solid-state batteries will be able to provide for a smaller battery pack, increase safety, and for higher energy density allowing EVs to travel further on a single charge.

Right now, only a single EV manufacturer has released a fully commercial EV with a solid-state battery. The Nio ET7 boast a solid-state battery capable of achieving a range of over 1,000km. QuantumScope and Toyota have already committed to developing solid-state batteries too.

Given the current technology and price of a full EV battery, it seems likely that automotive OEMs will continue to develop batteries with hybrid models instead of a full transition to EV. A full conversion towards EVs will gradually happen in time but is still a long road ahead.

Traditional automotive OEMs are simply not ready with the inherent transitionary risk especially when it comes to production, assembly, and roll out of EVs. Furthermore, majority of countries and cities lack the infrastructure to serve and maintain EVs.

Encouraging policy responses by the government is a way forward and can help with achieving a conducive ecosystem for EVs. The US recently unveiled a US$2 trillion infrastructure plan aimed at encouraging Americans to switch their gasoline powered vehicles to electric ones and called for a national network of half a million electric vehicle chargers within the decade.

Also Read: Indian electric vehicle makers need to improve the perception on quality — Ather Energy CEO Tarun Mehta

Meanwhile, in Norway, where EV sales accounted for 42 per cent of the market in 2019, favourable policies and progressive policies such as the elimination of annual road tax, purchase or import tax, and reduced parking fees has proven successful in encouraging consumers.

It is inevitable that 10 to 20 years from now a car we own will be in some way or form largely electric. But for now, it is unlikely for electric cars to take the market by storm in light of all these kinks that need to be smoothened out.

Editor’s note: e27 aims to foster thought leadership by publishing contributions from the community. This season we are seeking op-eds, analysis and articles on food tech and sustainability. Share your opinion and earn a byline by submitting a post.

Join our e27 Telegram group, FB community or like the e27 Facebook page

Image credit: Jp Valery on Unsplash

The post Thinking out loud: Are electric vehicles as sustainable as we believe? appeared first on e27.

,
electric vehicles

The core of modern civilisation lies in our mobility. Mobility impacts many aspects of life and as our lives grow more individual, it helps us in reaching towards the indispensable.

The next generation will see a transformative shift towards electrification in automobiles, moving away from internal combustion engines (ICE) that will likely be phased out.

The global electric vehicle (EV) market was valued at US$162 billion in 2019 and is projected to be valued at US$1,212 billion by 2027. An increase in demand for fuel-efficient, high-performance, and low-emission vehicles along with stringent government rules and regulations toward vehicle emission will supplement the growth of the electric vehicle market.

EV batteries remain the main barrier in the conversion to electric vehicles. Once only seen fit to power small consumer electronic goods such as alarm clocks and laptops, batteries are now moving upstream to power larger appliances from e-bikes to vehicles. Driving the move towards electrification is the rapid development of lithium-ion batteries.

The International Energy Agency (IEA) in its 2020 Global EV Outlook highlighted that sales of EVs in 2019 grew by 2.1 million worldwide. This boosted total stock in the market to 7.2 million from 5.1 million in 2018.

Electric cars in 2019 registered a 40 per cent year-on-year increase, accounting for 2.6 per cent of global car sales – roughly one per cent of global car stock. The rise and adoption of EVs are a sharp contrast to 2010 where only about 17,000 electric cars were on the road.

As countries try to reduce their carbon emissions and footprint in line with The Paris Agreement, EVs and batteries will play a crucial role moving forward.

Also Read: “Singapore isn’t ready for mass adoption of EVs yet; hybrid may be better for the present”

An EV battery presently accounts for almost 30 per cent of the total cost of an electric vehicle. Thus lies the main pain point faced by battery manufacturers and automotive OEMs – the cost to manufacture these batteries.

Developments in battery technology and manufacturing capabilities have driven prices of lithium-ion batteries down from US$1,000 a kilowatt-hour in 2010 to an average of US$156 per kilowatt-hour as of the end of 2019.

Although prices of batteries have significantly decreased, it has yet to reach the price-parity ratio suitable for mass adoption.

With the future of electrification on the horizon, existing traditional automotive manufacturers are converting and diverting resources to develop EVs. Together with new and upcoming companies that are either developing EVs and/or other related EV components such as battery swaps and charging stations, this space is heating up.

While Chinese EVs are focused on the hybrid model of battery swaps and charging stations, Tesla and other manufacturers in the West are adopting the Tesla model of building charging stations with high-powered piles.

Chinese EV maker Nio pioneered battery swapping technology in 2014. It has surpassed two million battery swaps and has over 190 Power Swap Stations in 59 Chinese cities. Nio’s battery swapping station only requires three-minutes to swap a depleted battery with a fully charged battery.

In addition to the battery swapping stations, Nio provides charging stations similar to Tesla’s fast chargers dubbed “Power Chargers” – currently the world’s slimmest and takes half an hour to charge to 80 per cent from 20 per cent.

The biggest advantage of battery swapping is the reduction in costs and thus prices of cars.

Also Read: Grab, Hyundai launches their first electric vehicle service in Indonesia

That said, many battery experts argue that battery swaps only serve as a transitional solution for consumer vehicles at this point and may face scalability issues for large commercial vehicles.

Challenges remain in the production of lithium-ion batteries despite the drop in production costs as it is still in its infancy and many variables remain uncertain.

Production of lithium-ion batteries face environmental and structural issues and continue to fuel debate. Extraction of lithium results in energy and water wastage, with long term impact found in the surrounding soil and water quality.

On average, producing an EV contributes twice as much to its Global Warming Potential (GWP) and uses double the amount of energy compared to a standard combustion engine. The fabrication of an EV battery accounts for 70 per cent of the EV GWP and is likely to result in emissions of more than eight tonnes of carbon dioxide.

The world’s biggest EV battery maker Contemporary Amperex Technology Ltd (CATL) has invested in overseas plants in Germany and Indonesia. Growing appetite for batteries has led to higher demand for cobalt and other critical minerals important to battery manufacturing.

In a bid to fulfil the surge in demand and to reduce dependency on critical minerals, cobalt which was once seen as the heart of lithium-ion batteries is being steadily reduced in content.

This was in part due to the negative connotation attached to it. Cobalt comes predominantly from the Democratic Republic of Congo where workers exposed to terrible conditions mine and extract the mineral, earning it a nickname as “Blood Cobalt”.

Looking beyond the limitations of lithium-ion batteries, the commercial use of solid-state lithium-ion in EVs would mitigate a majority of the current issues faced and could fundamentally change the perception of EVs with the general public.

Also Read: ION Mobility secures US$3.3M to drive SEA’s 200M motorcycle users to use EVs, starting with Indonesia

A key concern with consumers is the range and distance at which the cars can travel. The Tesla Model S Long Range currently holds the longest range, going a maximum of 600km under ideal situations.

A recent study by Castrol noted that  469km is the minimum range an EV needs to cover to ensure the occupants does not succumb to range anxiety under daily operations.

The long-term future of EVs lies in the development of solid-state batteries. Solid-state batteries will be able to provide for a smaller battery pack, increase safety, and for higher energy density allowing EVs to travel further on a single charge.

Right now, only a single EV manufacturer has released a fully commercial EV with a solid-state battery. The Nio ET7 boast a solid-state battery capable of achieving a range of over 1,000km. QuantumScope and Toyota have already committed to developing solid-state batteries too.

Given the current technology and price of a full EV battery, it seems likely that automotive OEMs will continue to develop batteries with hybrid models instead of a full transition to EV. A full conversion towards EVs will gradually happen in time but is still a long road ahead.

Traditional automotive OEMs are simply not ready with the inherent transitionary risk especially when it comes to production, assembly, and roll out of EVs. Furthermore, majority of countries and cities lack the infrastructure to serve and maintain EVs.

Encouraging policy responses by the government is a way forward and can help with achieving a conducive ecosystem for EVs. The US recently unveiled a US$2 trillion infrastructure plan aimed at encouraging Americans to switch their gasoline powered vehicles to electric ones and called for a national network of half a million electric vehicle chargers within the decade.

Also Read: Indian electric vehicle makers need to improve the perception on quality — Ather Energy CEO Tarun Mehta

Meanwhile, in Norway, where EV sales accounted for 42 per cent of the market in 2019, favourable policies and progressive policies such as the elimination of annual road tax, purchase or import tax, and reduced parking fees has proven successful in encouraging consumers.

It is inevitable that 10 to 20 years from now a car we own will be in some way or form largely electric. But for now, it is unlikely for electric cars to take the market by storm in light of all these kinks that need to be smoothened out.

Editor’s note: e27 aims to foster thought leadership by publishing contributions from the community. This season we are seeking op-eds, analysis and articles on food tech and sustainability. Share your opinion and earn a byline by submitting a post.

Join our e27 Telegram group, FB community or like the e27 Facebook page

Image credit: Jp Valery on Unsplash

The post Thinking out loud: Are electric vehicles as sustainable as we believe? appeared first on e27.

Leave a Reply